Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Judge Backs Atheist Parolee who Refused God-Based Treatment

Here is some great news on the legal front for atheists. A judge in Northern California sided with an atheist who was forced, as part of his parole from prison, to attend the heavily religious Alcoholics Anonymous program. Barry Hazle kept complaining to his parole officer that he wanted a non-religious drug-rehab program, but the parole officer ignored his requests.

But Hazle was persistent, though consistently polite and non-confrontational. He continued to go to AA, but also continued to bug his parole officer. In frustration his parole officer finally arrested him and sent him back to prison for three more months.

The judge's ruling was perfect, saying the parole officer's behavior ran "afoul of the prohibition against the state's favoring religion in general over non-religion." Hazle is now suing the state for damages related to the extra three months of incarceration he had to server merely for being an atheist.

Hazle's case also prompted the state parole board to clarify their rules. They now state emphatically that the parole board cannot compel anyone to take part in any religious activity.

My hat is off to Hazle. He ran afoul of the law and served his time for it, but then he had the courage to stand up for his rights. Like so many great activists, he was polite and congenial, yet he didn't back down. He was willing to take the risk, and in doing so, he helped end one more bit of state-sponsored discrimination in the State of California.

And by the way, I have huge admiration for Alcoholics Anonymous. Their twelve-step program is a lifesaver for millions, and the dedication of their volunteer counselors is incredible. Keep up the good work, AA!


  1. While I don’t doubt the dedication of their volunteers, I was under the impression that AA actually had a very low success rate, hardly any better than spontaneous remission.

  2. Eric - Check out today's blog. Thanks for your comment!

  3. I liked your post . hey check out this atheist rap video http://digg.com/general_sciences/Atheist_Rapper_Win

  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

  5. Your comments in the article about admiring AA are indicative of the success that AA had had in promoting itself in the public eye. Even a skeptical person such as yourself did not know that AA is essentially religion. It is based on faith. It presupposes to treat a 'disease' but it does not use science and doesn't even consider adapting to new knowledge.

    AA is an outgrowth of movements in the Christian church, which is not well known. Worst of all is it's bad habit of aggressively inserting itself into people's lives when they are very vulnerable. AA, although it is religious based (courts have ruled it is) has a powerful monopoly within the medical addiction treatment industry. This paradox is not well known.

    Thanks for considering Eric's comment and changing your mind when confronted with evidence. Enjoying the blog.


Dear readers -- I am no longer blogging and after leaving these blogs open for two years have finally stopped accepting comments due to spammers. Thanks for your interest. If you'd like to write to me, click on the "Contact" link at the top. Thanks! -- CJ.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.