Monday, August 9, 2010

Christianity is Dying - The Story Behind Anne Rice's Defection

The recent flurry of news reports and blogs about Anne Rice's defection from Christianity has been fun, but most writers missed the story behind it. Anne Rice isn't just an oddity or an exception. She's not one of those rugged individualist authors (though she certainly is unique) trying to hack a new path through the jungles of religion.

No, the real story is how utterly common these defections are becoming.

According to a new LA Times story, defection from organized religion is becoming so frequent among young people that a high-profile case like Anne Rice is barely news any more. "Rice is merely one of millions of Americans who have opted out of organized religion in recent years," according to the Times.

The Times goes on to cite the now-famous 2008 Pew study that showed 1 in 6 people in America are not part of any specific religion, a number that jumps to 1 in 4 for young adults 20-30 years old. "American Christianity is not well, and there's evidence to indicate that its condition is more critical than most realize – or at least want to admit."

This is particularly bad news for religion, and Christianity in particular, because of the two-generation effect. Generally speaking, to make religion "stick" requires a strong indoctrination. Although these non-affiliated Americans still believe in God, most of their children will be agnostics at best, and more likely atheists.

People like Anne Rice are concrete evidence that we're well into the first generation of the two-generation loss-of-faith process. If 25% of young adults (the very population that has children) don't go to church, and thereby don't expose their children to the indoctrination that's necessary for religion to "stick," then in twenty years at least 25% of Americans will be atheist or agnostic. Add to that the normal attrition rate (people who go to college, for example, are far less likely to be religious), and it's possible that within forty years the majority of Americans won't be religious at all. Among the remaining half that is still religious, there will undoubtedly be yet another generation of those abandoning the organized churches.


  1. You have to remember that it wasn't that long ago that Anne Rice became a fundamentalist Christian and denounced all of her silly vampire books. She doesn't strike me as someone who is particularly stable to begin with, she leaps from thing to thing, looking for something that I doubt she knows what it is. I don't take her so-called defection as anything meaningful in and of itself, tomorrow she'll adopt Islam or something and in another couple of years, she'll defect once again.

    She seems to be all-around defective.

    However, the rest of your points are well made, Christianity, and indeed all religion, is in trouble. As human technology and society move forward, there's less and less call for magical men in the sky to explain the world around us and that means, there's little reason to buy into the religious nonsense, especially as we see the horrors of religion in action in suicide bombers and pedophile priests.

    Goodbye religion and good riddance.

  2. I had no idea she had gone fundie. I thought she was Wiccan for years. Ah, well.... guess I need to stay more up to date on such things.

  3. This is a good illustration of why we shouldn't use celebrities as our spiritual leaders. Just because someone is a good author, football player, actor, or whatever doesn't mean they know anything about spiritual matters. Celebrities have no unique expertise in religion.

    But really, the blog wasn't about Anne Rice, it was about Christianity dying and the fact that Rice's defection isn't even surprising these days.


Dear readers -- I am no longer blogging and after leaving these blogs open for two years have finally stopped accepting comments due to spammers. Thanks for your interest. If you'd like to write to me, click on the "Contact" link at the top. Thanks! -- CJ.

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.